Last Updated on Monday, 21 September 2009 14:50 Written by Heather Mohan-Gibbons Wednesday, 19 August 2009 13:30
There is a lot of discussion lately about the right way to train a dog because of some techniques that are being shown on different television shows.
It seems like reinforcement techniques have become more popular over the past ten years or so, but now it seems that the older styles of training are coming back into vogue.
Could you explain what it means to use punishment and reinforcement? Also, why did the use of punishment go "out of style" in favor of reinforcement and which technique do you think is better?
To change behavior, all techniques must follow the ‘rules’ of learning theory in order to be effective. Learning theory is rooted in science and functions like gravity; it surrounds us and affects us whether we learn about it or not. Both punishment and reinforcement compose this learning theory and both work to change behavior.
Punishment vs. Reinforcement
The message behind punishment is to stop a behavior and reinforcement informs the animal what to do. We can then add or remove things to get these behaviors. There is a plethora of information on the web about this learning theory quadrant if you want to know more. No matter what method you are using, realize it is the animal that decides if it is a punishment or a reinforcer. For example, kneeing dog in the chest for jumping may create fear in one and play in another.
Are You Reinforcing the Right Behavior?
Behavior exists because of feedback we get when we act a certain way. That feedback is a consequence, and is either something pleasant that we work to get or something unpleasant that we work to avoid. We are experts at shaping behaviors that we don’t like in our dogs (and our children) because we tend to give attention when they are behaving poorly and ignore them when they are behaving well.
Saying "no" does not give the dog enough information for behavior change. Your success is rooted in saying "yes"; defining what you want and reinforcing that instead. Does your dog jump on people at the door? Rather than holding him by the collar and telling him no, teach him that reinforcement ONLY comes when his body is under his own control.
Where Does the Use of Punishment In Training Come From?
Historically, we have always used punishment based training to get animals to obey us. We used a whip to train tigers, spurs for horses, prong collars for dogs, we even created “shock backpacks” for children in the 60’s who misbehaved. The goal with punishment is to use pain or discomfort to stop behaviors. Check out Punishment Fallout on my website, Collected Wisdom Animal Behavior, for more on the outcomes of this type of punishment.
Perhaps it was that way simply because we did not know enough about the mind, learning, or animal emotions to know any better. Dolphin training in the 60’s forced us to be more creative and use reinforcing methods mostly because we couldn’t lasso marine mammals into submission. Karen Pryor among others lead positive reinforcement training into the canine world and now it widely used worldwide on every species.
Progress
We have come a long way in the past 30 years. We don’t use shock for our children anymore. Many countries are outlawing prong collars and shock collars due to the detrimental effects now widely known. Punishment techniques have fallen out of favor by professionals and have been replaced by methods that are still effective but do not create fear or aggression. It might appear more popular because it is now being channeled into your living room, but be assured this is not what is being presented in the journals and at the annual conferences.
Behavior Change Without Punishment
The profession of animal behavior has created more humane ways to treat our companions. This model from the
Hierarchy of Behavior Change Procedures for Humane and Effective
Practice (see image) was initially created for the behavioral treatment of children to help stop abuse and mistreatment.
The process is to start at the top and work down through each level until the behavior is modified. Punishment is on the list, but it is the very last option. First try all other techniques that are both effective and humane and you will find that beha vior change most often occurs in the first 3-4 levels. You will rarely find yourself moving all the way to the bottom. This model ensures that that we as professionals are remaining ethical in our practice and that above all, we do no harm by the animal.
Heather Mohan-Gibbons is an Associate Certified Applied Animal Behaviorist. She has a Master of Science degree, is a Certified Pet Dog Trainer and Registered Veterinary Technician, making her uniquely qualified to handle a variety of species and behavior problems. Her business is Collected Wisdom Animal Behavior. To learn more about Heather, visit Collected Wisdom Animal Behavior online: http://cwanimalbehavior.com
You can also find Heather on BrewCityTails, Milwaukee's social network for pet lovers.
If you have a question an upcoming column from Heather This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it .
Set as favorite
Email this
Hits: 1158
Trackback(0)
TrackBack URI for this entry
Comments (0)
Subscribe to this comment's feed
| < Prev | Next > |
|---|
